Golden Mountain Dog vs. Estrela Mountain Dog: What’s the Difference?
What is a Golden Mountain Dog? Is an Estrela Mountain Dog related to this mix? This is a question we get asked a lot, I know we can’t believe it either. But hopefully this comparison will give you a clear understanding of the 2 dog types, highlight which one might be right for you, and explain why an Estrela is not related to the Golden Mountain Dog. Even if they both are big dogs, with Mountain in their name,
While they may share some similarities, these breeds differ significantly in origin, purpose, and temperament. Understanding their unique traits can help you decide which dog is the best fit for your lifestyle and needs. We are not here to yuck somebody’s yum, and we are not taking a side in the Purebred vs Hybrid Dog is Healthier arguments.
The reality is: Dogs need ethical breeders that care and educate. And puppy seekers deserve to be informed about the pros and cons of different breeds and options.
Comparison: Estrela Mountain Dog vs. Golden Mountain Dog
| Feature | Estrela Mountain Dog | Golden Mountain Dog |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Portugal (landrace breed) | Hybrid of Golden Retriever and Bernese Mountain Dog |
| Purpose | Family and Livestock Guardian | Family companion |
| Size | 85-130 lbs, robust and muscular | 70-120 lbs, sturdy and shorter |
| Coat | Dense, weather-resistant, sheds in spring (long or short) | Medium to long, thick, shedding coat |
| Colors | Fawn, brindle, wolf gray (often with a black mask) | Black, white, brown, or golden |
| Temperament | Independent, loving with family, protective, and loyal | Friendly, affectionate, and social |
| Health | Low COI, fewer genetic health issues then most purebreds | Potential for inherited issues like cancer due to parent breeds |
| Exercise Needs | Low-Medium as an adult; thrives with yard and purposeful activity | Moderate; enjoys walks, playtime, and interaction |
| Training | Requires gentle but confident training due to independence | May be independent if like a Berner, may be eager to please |
| Lifespan | 10-14 years | 8-12 years |
| Price | $2,500-$5,000 (rare breed with limited numbers) | $800-$2,000 depending on breeder and location |
| Value | Elite, rare working breed with a rich history; ideal for farms or estates. High demand due to rarity and purpose. | More common designer breed; great for families seeking a loving pet but with potential health risks. |
| Suitability | Ideal for family guardians, rural Estates and working roles | Best for families seeking a loving companion |
What is a Golden Mountain Dog?
Golden Mountain Retriever Dog:
The Golden Mountain Dog is a hybrid breed, a cross between a Golden Retriever and a Bernese Mountain Dog. This mix aims to combine the affectionate and friendly nature of the Golden Retriever with the gentle, loyal, and striking appearance of the Bernese Mountain Dog. As a designer breed, Golden Mountain Dogs have become increasingly popular over the last decade for families seeking a loving and social pet.
If you’re looking for a trusted Golden Mountain Dog Breeder or Golden Mountain Dog Puppies for sale, it’s essential to research breeders who prioritize health and temperament.
What is a Estrela Mountain Dog?
The Estrela Mountain Dog, on the other hand, is an ancient purebred breed originating from Portugal. Named after the Serra da Estrela mountain range, these dogs have been used for centuries as family companions and livestock guardians. Bred to protect sheep and goats from predators, Estrelas are known for their courage, independence, and dedication to their duties. This ancient breed remains relatively rare outside its homeland, although its reputation is growing among farmers and livestock owners worldwide.
The Parent Breeds of the Golden Mountain Dog?
Golden Retrievers:
Golden Retrievers are celebrated for their friendly, intelligent, and eager-to-please nature. They were originally bred in Scotland as hunting dogs and quickly gained popularity as family pets. However, the breed’s popularity has led to a high coefficient of inbreeding (COI), contributing to a range of health issues, including cancer, hip dysplasia, and heart conditions. Golden Retriever Breed Info
Bernese Mountain Dogs:
Bernese Mountain Dogs are known for their gentle and affectionate demeanor. Originating from Switzerland, these dogs were traditionally used as draft animals and farm companions. Like Golden Retrievers, Bernese Mountain Dogs face significant health challenges, including a high prevalence of cancer, hip and elbow dysplasia, and a shortened lifespan due to their high COI.
Link: Bernese Mountain Dog Breed Overview
Physical Characteristics
Golden Mountain Dog:
Bernese Mountain Dog and Golden Retriever mix’s typically inherit a variety of traits from their parent breeds. They are large dogs, weighing between 75 and 120 pounds, with a thick, medium to long coat that can be black, white, brown, or golden.
Their appearance should be soft and approachable, reflecting their friendly and gentle nature. As a Bernese Mountain Dog Golden Retriever mix, these dogs boast the best features of both parent breeds, if you get lucky. The opposite could also be true.
Owners searching for a Mountain Dog Golden Retriever hybrid should be prepared to love the dog as an adult regardless of which parent it takes after.
Estrela Mountain Dog:
Estrela Mountain Dogs are also large, robust animals, weighing 85 to 130 pounds. They have a dense, weather-resistant coat that comes in two varieties: long and short. Common colors include fawn, brindle, and wolf gray, often with a black mask. Estrelas exude a commanding presence, reflecting their working heritage and protective instincts.
They are not a dog that necessarily wants to meet everyone you meet on the street. But they do well in public settings if socialized properly as a pup. They are a dignified dog.
Temperament
Golden Mountain Dog:
Golden Mountain Dogs are known for their sweet and social personalities. They are excellent family pets, thriving on human interaction and affection. These dogs are generally good with children and other pets, making them ideal for households that prioritize companionship. Their friendly demeanor means they may not be the best guard dogs. If you’re interested in adopting a Golden Retriever Bernese Mountain Dog mix, finding a reputable Golden Mountain Dog Breeder is key to ensuring a well-rounded puppy.
Estrela Mountain Dog:
Estrelas are independent and protective, traits honed over generations of guarding livestock. While they can form strong bonds with their family, they are naturally wary of strangers, making them excellent guardians. Their temperament requires a confident owner who can provide consistent training and socialization to ensure a well-rounded companion.
Exercise and Training Needs
Estrela Mountain Dog:
Estrelas need ample space and opportunities to exercise, but they are not high energy dogs as adults. They do not need big acreage like some of the other LGD breeds tend to want. They are satisfied staying closer to their families, and livestock particularly if they are working as livestock guardians.
Their independent nature can make recall training more challenging, especially for first-time dog owners. Positive reinforcement and patience are key to building a strong relationship with an Estrela.
Fenced properties are recommended, due to their size and ability to travel far quickly, if they were to pursue a predator for example.
Golden Mountain Dog:
Golden Mountain Dogs enjoy moderate activity and require daily exercise to stay healthy and happy. They are intelligent, making them relatively easy to train. Regular walks, playtime, and mental stimulation will keep them content.
If you’re searching for GMD Puppies for sale, consider your commitment to providing adequate physical and mental stimulation for this mixed breed.
Suitability for Different Lifestyles
GMD:
This breed is best suited for families looking for a loving, social dog that can adapt to various living situations, including suburban homes. They do not exhibit guardian instincts, and will have too much prey drive to be good livestock guardian dogs.
They thrive on companionship and are happiest when included in family activities. Families actively searching for a large breed family pet might find this mixed breed meets their needs.
EMD:
Estrelas excel in rural or farm settings where they can use their guarding instincts.
They are ideal for estate protection, and small farmers or ranchers who need a reliable livestock guardian.
However, they can also adapt to family life and are content to be with their owners.
Finding the Right Golden Mountain Dog Breeder
If you decide to go searching for Golden Mountain Dog Puppies for sale, working with a reputable breeder is crucial. A trustworthy dog breeder of any breed will prioritize the health, temperament, and well-being of their dogs.
Mixed Breeds tend to be very vulnerable to Puppy Mills and Back-yard Breeders, because there is no breed standard, or guidance. Any one looking to make a litter can go and find Craiglist parents and boom they are the newest fad breeder. You will risk getting a sick puppy or worse by dealing with these types of dog breeders.
As a Bernese/Retriever mix, these dogs can vary in personality and appearance. You will need to be prepared for basically whatever genes the pup might retain from the parent breed. This is why a good breeder would be critical.
Golden Mountain Dog Health Testing
The Golden Mountain Dog Breeder should be completing the recommend OFA testing of BOTH parent breeds, before making a mixed litter. This would include hips, elbows, eyes, hearts, etc.
Here is the link to the recommended health testing for the Golden Retriever Dog Breed.
Here is the link to the recommended health testing for the Bernese Mountain Dog Breed.
Puppies do not automatically come “healthy” if their parents were not. Yes, the risk of COI related issues will drop with a hybrid mix, but the puppies also are at risk to contract issues from either of their parent breeds.
Breeding “mixed breeds” just because they are supposedly healthier, without having any proof that they are actually healthier, is not the type of Breeder you want to risk getting a puppy from.
Dog breeder’s who are running a hybrid mixed breed program, may need to do even more health testing then the average purebred dog breeder. With great genetic diversity, comes more potential issues they may need to test for.
My Breeder Said My Dog Was Healthy via DNA Testing
One benefit of DNA testing is being able to tell know that you are actually getting the mix you think you are getting. If the breeder can provide you Embark results of the parents, you will probably not end up with a Dober Mountain Dog or something else you are not prepared for. This is a lot more common then you might think, especially in a hybrid mix where the pups can look like either parent breed.
DNA Testing is not a replacement for actual hip X-rays and heart exams. If your dog was swabbed for a saliva DNA test like Embark or Wisdom for example, this does not mean they cannot be severely dysplastic.
Health testing is a broad spectrum of tests. And we do not have tests for everything. That is why it is important to test what we can and make balanced choices regarding the results.
Health Concerns in Golden Mountain Dogs
While combining the Retriever and Bernese aims to reduce some health risks through hybrid vigor, poor breeding practices can negate these benefits. Without proper health testing, Golden Mountain Dogs may inherit the same genetic predispositions to cancer, joint issues, and heart disease. When searching for Golden Mountain Dog Puppies for sale, it is critical to ensure the breeder conducts thorough health evaluations of both parent breeds.
The Risks of Unethical Breeding in Mixed Breeds
Golden Mountain Dogs can be a purposeful mix of two beloved breeds, or they could be a nuerotic mess, depending on what breed stock they come from. Their health and temperament will depend heavily on responsible breeding. Without proper health testing and temperament evaluations, these hybrids may suffer from unpredictable behavioral traits and inherited health issues.
Prospective owners should seek out a reputable Golden Mountain Dog Breeder who prioritizes ethical practices and transparency.
Why the Estrela Mountain Dog Stands Out
Estrela Mountain Dogs are a landrace breed, meaning they evolved naturally over time to suit their environment, resulting in a highly diverse gene pool and low COI. Because we still have the short-hair and long-hair versions, we have retained more genetic diversity then the more domesticated breeds like the Bernese or Golden.
This genetic diversity makes Estrelas less prone to many common health issues found in purebred dogs. Additionally, their predictable temperament—developed through centuries of livestock guarding—makes them a reliable choice for families and farmers alike.
The Estrela’s natural robustness, longevity and adaptability are a testament to the value of preserving a landrace breed.
Golden Mountain Dog vs Estrela Mountain Dog Summary
Choosing between a Golden Mountain Dog and an Estrela Mountain Dog depends on your lifestyle, environment, and expectations.
If you need a courageous and loving guardian with a rich heritage, the Estrela Mountain Dog is unparalleled. They aren’t the kind of dog that everyone will have, or even should have. Most owners get one and are Estrela owners for life. They have that kind of effect, despite the breed quirks.
If you’re seeking a friendly, social family dog, the Golden Mountain Dog—a Mountain Dog Golden Retriever hybrid—might be right for you.
No matter which breed you choose, understanding their unique needs and characteristics will ensure a positive relationship with your new dog.
For those set on adopting a Golden Retriever Bernese Mountain Dog mix, finding Golden Mountain Dog Puppies for sale through a trusted breeder is the first step. Check out this Facebook page to connect with a community.
If you’re looking for an Estrela Mountain Dog, send us a message, we can help.
Related Posts You May Like:
Complete List of Whelping Supplies
Puppy Curriculum for Dog Breeders
Comments +